Supreme Court Rejects Redistricting Map

Set Text Size SmallSet Text Size MediumSet Text Size LargeSet Text Size X-Large
Updated: 2/24/2012 6:51 pm
 The Kentucky Supreme Court has blocked the use of new boundaries for Kentucky’s 138 legislative districts.  The decision came Friday afternoon, just hours after the state’s highest court heard oral arguments in the legal challenge to the new map.
The two page ruling rules the new redistricting law, which was passed last month, unconstitutional.  The justices, in a unanimous decision, ordered election officials to use the ten year old map for this year’s statehouse races. 
Time was a big reason because candidates have to be certified by Monday and the primary is set for May 22.  Thus, the high court did something it rarely does, conduct a hearing and issue a decision on the same day.
Carving out 100 House districts and 38 Senate districts is required by law once a decade because of population shifts.  The new law was challenge by three Republican State Representatives and Democrat Senator Kathy Stein, who would have been forced out of office at the end of 2012 by the new map.  The court challenged claimed the new boundaries split too many counties and exceeds the population deviation.
A circuit judge agreed earlier this month, putting the case on the fast track to the Supreme Court.
The attorney for the legislature, Sheryl Snyder, claimed the General Assembly deserved wiggle room.  "Is simply too inflexible a straight jacket to put on the General Assembly when they are engaged in the highly political issue of reapportioning the state,” said Snyder told the court during the hearing.
The attorney for the trio of GOP reps, Victor Maddox, claimed the new lines break a “clear and flexible rule.”
"It does not create the sort of standard less, ad hoc approach that the legislature would have this court adopt for no good reason,” said Maddox.
Stein’s attorney, Scott White, told the justices "this is really an easy case and there's no mystery."
Within a few hours, the high court had agreed, ruling the new boundaries unconstitutional and ordering the 2012 elections for all 100 House seats and half of the Senate’s 38 seats run in the old districts.
The court indicated it would issue a “full opinion” in the future.

Most Popular
Kentucky business unspooled as feds closed in
Louis Joseph Brothers used sales of military-grade electronics to Hong Kong to boost the revenue for his business, then resigned from the company he founded when federal investigators started questioning the sales and the company fell apart.
Ky. man sentenced to life without parole
A southern Kentucky man who pleaded guilty to murder, fetal homicide and other charges involving the stabbing death of a pregnant woman has been sentenced to life in prison without parole.
Jerry And Jack Cassidy Accused Of Indecent And Immoral Acts
New charges were filed against twin brothers in jail in Lexington for child pornography. On Tuesday, the two each had additional charges of indecent and immoral practices. Video Video
Update: Man Killed In Motorcycle Crash In Clark Co.
A Powell county man was killed on Tuesday night in a motorcycle crash on the Mt. Parkway in Clark county. Video Video
Man Accused of Selling Drugs in Danville Arrested in Nicholasville
A man wanted for allegedly selling drugs in Danville around a month ago has been caught in Nicholasville, according to Boyle County deputies.
Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital. supports children's privacy rights. All persons under the age of 13 MUST have parental permission to use this website and direct parental supervision is strongly recommended.